Sandwell’s Healthyish Menu

deliciously hearty & healthyish toasted SANDWICHES, made-to-order on our own freshly-baked bread.

packed full of flavor without preservatives, nitrates, pork, red meat, butter, cream, or anything fried. we serve awesome New York sandwiches, salads, sides & more that leave you feeling great.

hearty salads include our green goddess caesar salad and just the right sides like our mac & cheese & peas.

experience sandwell’s deliciously HEALTHYISH difference today!

The Best Turkey Meatball Sub in New York City, Gramercy Park and Upper West Side

Turkey Meatball Sub

The Best Vegetarian Truffled Mushroom Cheesesteak in New York City, Gramercy Park and Upper West Side

Mushroom Cheese"steak"

The Best Italian Chicken Pesto Burrata Sandwich in New York City, Gramercy Park and Upper West Side

Chicken Pesto Burrata

The Best Buffalo Chicken Sub In New York City, Gramercy Park and Upper West Side

Buffalo Chicken

healthyish SANDWICHES

Turkey Meatball Sub

turkey meatballs in classic sunday marinara sauce, provolone, parmesan, basil oil, arugula

Lunchbox Special

our own uncured maple turkey, thick-cut turkey bacon, cheddar, avocado mash, pickles, lettuce, tomato, dairy-free avocado ranch

Chicken Pesto Burrata

grilled chicken breast, basil pine nut pesto, whipped burrata, roasted red peppers, tomato, spinach

The Wild Bird

grilled chicken breast, provolone, turkey bacon bits, caramelized onions, pickles, lettuce, tomato, hot cherry peppers, dairy-free spicy secret sauce

Mushroom Cheese"steak"

truffled roasted mushrooms, cacio e pepe sauce, provolone, caramelized onions, roasted red peppers, (vegetarian)

Spicy Eggplant Parm

baked eggplant cutlet, whipped burrata, marinara, parmesan, calabrian chile oil, toasted breadcrumbs, arugula (vegetarian)

Broccoli Cheddar Melt

roasted broccoli, cheddar, turkey bacon bits, melty cheese sauce, caramelized onions, toasted breadcrumbs

The Remy (vegan)

roasted red peppers, baked eggplant cutlet, caramelized onions, cherry tomatoes, housemade zucchini pickles, basil oil, spinach & toasted cannellini spread

Chicken Parm

baked chicken cutlet, whipped burrata, marinara, parmesan, house-infused basil oil

Buffalo Chicken

baked chicken cutlet, buffalo sauce, blue cheese, pickled carrots and celery, lettuce, tomato, dairy-free avocado ranch

Green Goddess Chicken Caesar Sub

grilled chicken, green goddess caesar dressing, parmesan, romaine, cherry tomato, provolone

Spicy Chicken Banh Mi

lemongrass chicken, sriracha coulis, dairy-free basil jalapeno aioli, pickled veggies, cilantro

hearty SALADS

Green Goddess Caesar Salad

romaine, parmesan, green goddess caesar dressing, parmesan croutons, cherry tomatoes

Green Goddess Chicken Caesar Salad

grilled chicken breast, romaine, parmesan, green goddess caesar dressing, parmesan croutons, cherry tomatoes

Buffalo Chicken Salad

baked chicken cutlet, bleu cheese, romaine, pickled carrots and celery, dairy-free wing sauce dressing

Pesto Chicken Salad

grilled chicken breast, whipped burrata, spinach, arugula, cherry tomatoes, broccoli, pesto vinaigrette

Maple Cobb Salad

grilled chicken, turkey bacon, avocado mash, bleu cheese, romaine, spinach, tomato, maple dijon vinaigrette

Truffled Mushroom Salad (vegan)

truffled roasted mushrooms, broccoli, cherry tomatoes, mixed greens, maple dijon vinaigrette

tasty SIDES

Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie

rolled oats studded with chocolate chips

Mac & Cheese & Peas

cavatappi pasta, housemade cheese sauce, peas, breadcrumbs

Roasted Broccoli

vegan avocado ranch, toasted breadcrumbs

Dill Pickles

two kosher dill pickle spears

Cape Cod Potato Chips

kettle-cooked with sea salt

Turkey Meatballs

braised in housemade marinara, parmesan, arugula

Kid's Meal

choice of baked chicken cutlet or turkey meatballs. served with mac and cheese, roasted broccoli, and box of Mott's apple juice. limited to children under 13

BEVERAGES

Organic Black Iced Tea

Homemade Ginger Lemonade

Fresh-Roasted Coffee

Mighty Leaf Hot Teas

Saratoga Water

Spindrift Seltzer

Poppi Prebiotic Soda

Martinelli’s Apple Juice

Vita Coco Coconut Water

Food Allergy Warning

Please be advised that all of our menu items may contain or may have come in contact with gluten, nuts, tree nuts, peanuts, dairy, soy, eggs, fish, or sesame seeds.