Turkey Meatball Sub — The Sandwich That Started It All
Braised turkey meatballs in house-made Sunday sauce marinara, melted provolone, shaved parm, house-infused basil oil, and peppery arugula on house-baked semolina bread.
This is the one. The Turkey Meatball Sub is how Sandwell was born — the sandwich that proved you could make a meatball sub that's deeply satisfying without the post-lunch regret. Turkey meatballs braised in our house-made Sunday sauce marinara, topped with melted provolone, shaved parmesan, a drizzle of house-infused basil oil, and a handful of peppery arugula. All of it served on semolina bread we bake in-house and cold-proof for 24+ hours, so you get that perfect combination of crisp crust and soft, airy crumb. It's our top seller, and it's not close.
The secret isn't one ingredient — it's the way everything works together. The meatballs are baked, never fried, so you get clean flavor and tender texture without greasiness. The Sunday sauce marinara is made from scratch, the kind that simmers low and slow until it doesn't need any help. Provolone melts into the meatballs while shaved parm adds a sharper, nuttier layer. Basil oil and arugula cut through the richness so every bite stays balanced. Hearty, not heavy — that's the whole idea behind healthyish.
Whether you're grabbing lunch near Central Park, fueling up after a workout in Gramercy, or feeding the family on a night nobody wants to cook, the Turkey Meatball Sub delivers. Order online for pickup or delivery at getsandwell.com/order.
“Our favorite sandwich place in the neighborhood, we absolutely love the meatball sub! Great selection and fun specials each month. The staff is super nice and seem to genuinely enjoy their job and appreciate your patronage.” - Kelsey D
“YUM-this place was soooo good. I had had a full day of wandering the Natural History Museum and hadn't had much to eat all day, so this place was a godsend. They had a great selection of meat and meatless sandwiches and salads and the meatball sub, which apparently is very popular, was calling to me. This was the best sandwich I've had in a while. I can't even describe why. Every ingredient was fresh and warm and hearty. I felt like I was eating really quality food. Staff was nice and they have a 50% off "happy hour" deal if you're a member, which I totally would do if I lived closer. Wow” - Julia L
“Amazing sandwiches and I love how soft the bread is. Service is nice and I loved the turkey meatball sub. Would definitely come back.” - Prianka S
“A great UWS takeout spot! The workers are always fast and friendly and the turkey meatball sandwich is a great treat for when we don't feel like cooking.” - Tiaryn D
“Absolutely love getting a hot sandwich here to go! Their meatball sub is so tasty, I love coming here after my workout class to grab one. Thanks Sandwell!” - Vera M
“Food was quick and delicious! Also, the meatball sub is the best sandwich” - Henry W
“Excellent turkey meatball sandwich, served super hot and fresh (they make everything to order so you never get a sandwich that’s been sitting around). Staff was awesome, and the cashier showed a clear passion for the food as his recommendations were detailed and genuine, and importantly the place was very clean. Looking forward to coming back!” - Peyton M
"Had the turkey meatball sub a little while ago. Phenomenal! Not heavy, great taste and those meatballs and that bread are simply top notch." - Drew L.
"Excellent turkey meatball hero. Tasty bread, great sauce and tender and delicious turkey meatballs. Highly recommended." - Mark S.
"I got the turkey meatball sub and I really enjoyed it. The quality was great and the size was huge for the price!...My sandwich was ready really quickly and the inside is very cute and clean. I think their mission for healthy-ish sandwiches holds true, as I did not feel gross after eating it. I would definitely recommend trying this place!" - Claire G.
"Great clean eating food .. try the turkey meatball sandwich it's awesome... will definitely make it a regular" - David N.
Frequently Asked Questions About The Turkey Meatball Sub
What's in Sandwell's Turkey Meatball Sub? Sandwell's Turkey Meatball Sub features braised turkey meatballs in house-made Sunday sauce marinara, melted provolone, shaved parmesan, house-infused basil oil, and peppery arugula on house-baked semolina bread that's cold-proofed for 24+ hours.
Is Sandwell's Turkey Meatball Sub healthy? Sandwell's Turkey Meatball Sub is built around baked (never fried) turkey meatballs and scratch-made sauce, with no artificial ingredients. It's hearty and satisfying without the heaviness of a traditional meatball sub — that's what we mean by healthyish.
Does the Turkey Meatball Sub contain gluten? Our turkey meatballs contain gluten breadcrumbs (made from our own classic semolina bread) inside the meatball mix, so they cannot be made gluten-free.
Where can I order Sandwell's Turkey Meatball Sub in NYC? You can order the Turkey Meatball Sub at either Sandwell location — 412 Amsterdam Avenue on the Upper West Side or 250 3rd Avenue in Gramercy. Order online for pickup or delivery at getsandwell.com/order.
Can I order Sandwell's Turkey Meatball Sub for catering? Yes. The Turkey Meatball Sub is available through Sandwell's catering menu as part of our sandwich box platters. Visit getsandwell.com/cateringdirect to place a catering order.
Sandwell serves up the best Meatball Sub in New York City
A local favorite near the Upper West Side, Central Park, American Museum of Natural History, Gramercy Park, Union Square, Madison Square Park, Stuyvesant Town, Peter Cooper Village, East Village, Murray Hill, Kips Bay, Flatiron, NoMad, Stuyvesant Square, Baruch College, Empire State Building, Bellevue, NYU Langone, and New York University. Popular with New Yorkers and international visitors alike — freshly made, satisfying, and rooted in New York food culture.